Archive for the ‘Reformer vs. Regressive’ Category
Ali A. Rizvi vs. C. J. Werleman
Reformer vs. Regressive
The Rizvi/Werleman clash exemplifies this dialectic: reformed Islam vs. regressive Islam. At crux is the idea of cultural superiority or ethnic superiority. You cannot believe in both. You either believe cultures are equal but human subgroups are not (this makes you a bigot). OR: you believe that humans deserve equal treatment but cultures do not (this makes you a humanist).
Example: See Sarah Haider vs. Reza Aslan. Cultures that believe women/minorities (ethnic and religious)/homosexuals are inferior are, in fact, inferior to cultures that think women/minorities (ethnic and religious)/homosexuals deserve equal rights. The Reformer pushes humanism, the Regressive protects bigotry.
Reformer: One standard, believes humans deserve equal treatment but cultures don’t, objectively looks at religious texts; thinks South Asians, Africans, & Middle Easterners want equal rights, progress, and are able to enjoy and utilize free speech, including criticism.
Regressive: Two standards, believes cultures deserve equal treatment but humans don’t, selectively looks at religious texts; thinks South Asians, Africans, & Middle Easterners cannot handle equal rights or criticism.
Here are some past, present, and future battlers in this competition of ideas:
Reformer VS. Regressive
Raif Badawi (imprisoned) Ben Affleck
Karima Bennoune (father assassinated) Reza Aslan
Bassem Eid Max Blumenthal
Mona Eltahawy Glenn Greenwald
Sarah Haider Mehdi Hasan
Pervez Hoodbhoy Ibrahim Hooper
Waleed Al Husseini Nathan Lean
Kenan Malik Dean Obeidallah
Irshad Manji Mo Ansar
Faisal Saeed al Mutar Murtaza Hussain
Maajid Nawaz Rula Jebreal
Asra Nomani Linda Sarsour
Raheel Raza David Shariatmadari
Ali A . Rizvi C.J. Werleman
Ziauddin Sardar Cenk Uygur
Malala Yousafzai Sayeeda Warsi
Bassem Youssef Harris Zafar
For more on reformers and regressives, check out:
Who’s Who in Islam
Muslim Group Calls Out PC Culture for Being too Afraid to Take Down Islamic Extremism
The Regressive Shuffle – Connor McKenna
2015 – Rise of the Regressive
Time for Self-Examination – WaPost