Arguments Worth Having

Art = Absurdity = Provocation = Contemplation = Wisdom = Love

Letter to Larry Stone of the Seattle Times Regarding the Hall of Fame

with one comment

“I’m not going to let steroids association keep me from voting for a candidate.” – Larry Stone

“Dr. Thomas DeLoughery said Mr. Alzado died of complications of a rare form of brain cancer, which was diagnosed a year ago and which the athlete attributed to his years of taking massive doses of steroids to build and maintain a formidable physique.” – LA Times

I love the drama, character building, and competition sports involves. There are many life lessons. Sports can teach honor, fairness, and respect. I’ve attacked the dorks at KJR for lacking this honor (The Bigger Dance and Seattle Mariners Sign a Convicted Rapist and Felon), and now it’s Hall of Fame time and a beef with Seattle Times columnist Larry Stone:

McGwire, Bonds, & Giambi

Dear Larry Stone,

I respect and follow you in the paper and sports talk radio, but I disagree hugely on one issue. On January 4 you disclosed your Hall of Fame ballot in the Seattle Times. Yesterday the vote came out. You voted for these ten: Jeff Bagwell, Craig Biggio, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Edgar Martinez, Mike Piazza, Tim Raines, Curt Schilling, Alan Trammell and Larry Walker. You also mentioned that, could you have, you would have voted or given strong consideration to Mark McGwire and Sammy “corked bat” Sosa. This alone should disqualify you from the “Sports Journalism Hall of Fame.”

Biggio, Bagwell, Martinez et al are worthy considerations. But Bonds and Clemens? McGwire and Sosa? No-way no-how not-ever not-in-hell not-in-this world. Never. Drawing the line at Palmeiro, as you did, doesn’t cut it. Here’s why:

PED user Chris Benoit murdered his wife and son, and then committed suicide

No athlete should have to choose between performance enhancing drugs or health. Just take a look at dead-at-43 Lyle Alzado. The harms caused to the user are many:  acne, enlarged prostrate, testicular atrophy, liver damage, hair loss, sterility, not to mention psychosis and violent tendencies, as witnessed when wrestler Chris Benoit killed his wife.

Likewise, no athlete who plays fair should lose his or her job or have to compete against opponents who use steroids or other performance enhancing drugs. Ever. It doesn’t matter if others may have done steroids or worse but never were caught or lived in a different age. Integrity now cannot be compromised because dubious behavior has been tolerated in the past. To ensure a richer future in sports, we must change the culture. I want this for my children, Mr. Stone, don’t you?

Therefore, to get into the Hall of Fame, if you think a player used, then he has no place in baseball’s shrine. Larry, your views do not merit the “hate” mail you claim you have received, they are your opinions. But my opinion is that the more people who share your opinion, the greater the harm to future generations. Evidently you are not so naïve to think Bonds and Clemens didn’t use. But you voted for them anyway. Therefore, you have elected to be wrong.

Sincerely,

Caleb Powell

Advertisements

Written by Caleb Powell

January 10, 2013 at 4:22 pm

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Several major problems with your argument:

    1. Neither Lyle Alzado nor Chris Benoit (or his family) died as a result of PED usage, according to the doctors of each individual. Alzado died because of a brain tumor, while Benoit’s behavior was attributed to having severe dementia.

    2. Steroids did not give the current generation an advantage that their predecessors lacked. They have been used at alarming rates in MLB clubhouses since at least 1973, according to a government study cited in the Mitchell Report.

    3. The Hall of Fame is already packed with cheaters of all types – PED usage included. The issue dates back as far as 1889, when HOF pitcher Pud Galvin openly used the Brown-Sequard elixir (a precurser to modern steroids) in order to enhance performance. There are also numerous players who have admitted to using amphetamines, which are just as illegal as steroids and have been since 1971. And this is before getting into all of the players who doctored equipment, stole signs, or did everything they could to artificially limit the competition via segregation.

    4. You are missing the point about what separates Rafael Palmeiro apart: He actually tested positive for steroid usage under MLB’s testing system. This cannot be said about Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, or Sosa.

    jah05r

    February 9, 2013 at 1:23 pm


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s